Robert FitzWalter - Baron of Little Dunmow
Marshal of the Army of God
Robert FitzWalter, Baron of Little Dunmow in Essex and lord of Baynard's Castle in London, was the leading baronial opponent of King John and one of the twenty-five sureties of Magna Carta. Elected "Marshal of the Army of God and Holy Church" by the rebel barons in 1215, he led them into London, held Rochester Castle against the king, and later invited Prince Louis of France to take the English throne, before he was captured at the Battle of Lincoln.
Robert was born around 1180, the son of Walter FitzRobert, lord of Little Dunmow in Essex and of Baynard's Castle in London, and of Matilda, daughter of Richard de Lucy. His brother Walter became archdeacon of Hereford. Robert succeeded his father in 1198 and inherited a barony of more than 66 knight's fees. The family held the soke of Baynard's Castle, an office that made its holder the castellan and chief banneret of the City and gave the family close ties with the Londoners. Robert married Gunnor, the daughter and heiress of Robert de Valognes, whose inheritance brought him 32 more knight's fees, together with a claim to Hertford Castle. A French chronicler called him "one of the greatest men in England and one of the most powerful." In August 1202, King John made him warden of Hertford Castle and released him from his family's debts to Jewish moneylenders.
In 1203, John sent Robert to Normandy, where he and Saer de Quincy were made joint governors of Le Vaudreuil. They surrendered the castle to King Philip II of France without a fight and were held at Compiègne until a ransom of 5,000 marks was paid. Contemporaries mocked the surrender as cowardice or collusion, and the real reasons for it remain unclear. The two men became close companions and brothers-in-arms.
In 1212, chroniclers linked Robert and Eustace de Vesci to a plot against John. Roger of Wendover blamed a dispute over Binham Priory, and one account says that John tried to seduce Robert's daughter Matilda. A more plausible cause is that John threatened to hang Geoffrey de Mandeville, to which Robert is said to have replied, "You will see two thousand knights in your land before you hang him!" When John demanded hostages from the barons, Robert fled to France and was condemned to exile. John seized his estates and destroyed Baynard's Castle on January 14th, 1213. After John made peace with the pope, Robert was allowed to return, and his estates were restored on July 19th, 1213.
Robert was present at Bury St Edmunds in November 1214, when the barons swore to make war on John if he did not grant a charter. In Easter week 1215, he was the first-named of the barons who gathered at Stamford, and on May 5th, at Brackley, the rebels renounced their oaths to John and chose Robert as their leader, with the title "Marshal of the Army of God and Holy Church." On May 17th, 1215, he entered London at the head of the rebel army, and the city became their base. He was one of the twenty-five barons appointed to enforce Magna Carta, which was sealed in June, and on June 19th, he was named first among the barons in the agreement to hand London over to them by August 15th if John kept the charter. Its clause forbidding exile without a lawful trial is thought to refer to his own case, and he also regained custody of Hertford Castle.
When the First Barons' War began in August 1215, Robert secretly occupied Rochester Castle with a large force, but John's troops burned the bridge, and on October 11th, Robert retreated to London. The royalists took the town and besieged the castle, and the garrison, who felt he had abandoned them, surrendered on November 10th. On December 16th, the rebel barons were excommunicated by name.
Robert and Saer de Quincy then went to France to offer the English throne to Prince Louis, son of Philip II, and Louis landed at Pegwell Bay on May 21st, 1216. On June 3rd, Robert and the mayor of London, William Hardel, led the barons and citizens in paying homage to Louis. After John died on October 19th, 1216, most English barons turned to his young son, Henry III, but Robert stayed with Louis. When Louis captured Hertford Castle on December 6th, 1216, he refused to restore it to Robert, saying that a traitor to his own lord could not be trusted.
In April 1217, Robert helped relieve the siege of Saer de Quincy's castle at Mountsorrel. On May 20th, at the Battle of Lincoln, he advised attacking the royalist relief force, but the barons overruled him and withdrew into the city. William Marshal and the Earl of Chester then broke into the city and defeated the rebels and their French allies, capturing most of the rebel leaders, including Robert and his son. The Treaty of Lambeth ended the war on September 11th, 1217, and Robert was released on October 8th. The reissue of the charter showed that his cause had won, even though he had lost the battle.
In 1219, Robert joined the Fifth Crusade with Saer de Quincy and took part in the later stages of the siege of Damietta, which fell on November 6th, 1219, but he fell sick and went home before the crusade ended in 1221. Reconciled with Henry III, he witnessed the king's confirmation of Magna Carta on February 11th, 1225. He died on December 9th, 1235, and was buried before the high altar at Dunmow Priory. Robert was haughty and quick to take offense, and he spent much of his career trying to recover Hertford Castle, which he claimed through his wife. The chronicler Matthew Paris, who disliked him, still wrote a generous obituary, calling him a "noble baron, illustrious by his birth, and renowned for his martial deeds."
A later legend, first found in the Dunmow chronicle, says that John tried to seduce Robert's daughter Matilda and had her poisoned when she refused, which drove her father to lead the revolt. Plays and poems of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries merged her with Maid Marian, but historians regard the story as a later embellishment. It was also believed in the seventeenth century that Robert, or one of his successors, founded the custom of the Dunmow Flitch, in which a flitch of bacon is awarded to a couple who have lived in harmony for a year and a day.




